Hot Buttered Coffee

Try our coffee version of the classic hot toddy this holiday season.

Photo by: The Workshop Kitchen

The Workshop Kitchen

Coming up with ideas for recipes is a lot like travel: I don’t always know exactly where I am going. In this case, I started out thinking about grog—more specifically, "the grog that doesn't make you groggy." But then I was worried about cooking the coffee long enough to steep in the spices as you would for traditional grog (also, there is a citrus element that I wasn't sure about). So my idea shifted over to more of a hot-buttered-rum approach. You start with a "batter" of dark brown sugar, butter and spices that is ready to go at room temperature and can be made ahead of time. It’s a great recipe to keep around for parties, because you just put a spoon into a mug, add a shot of dark rum, cover with hot coffee and everything stays fresh.

Yield: Enough for about 12 mugs

Ingredients

For the batter:
1 stick unsalted butter, at room temperature
2 cups dark brown sugar
1/2 tsp. vanilla extract
3/4 tsp. ground cinnamon
1/2 tsp. ground ginger
1/4 tsp. nutmeg
1/4 tsp. dried orange peel
1/8 tsp. ground clove
A pinch of cayenne pepper
A pinch of salt

Fresh-brewed coffee
Dark rum

Place batter ingredients in a medium-sized mixing bowl and cream together (using a spatula) until well combined. If making ahead, transfer to a container with a tightly fitting lid and refrigerate. Pull out of the refrigerator about an hour before serving to let the mixture warm up to room temperature.

For each mug of coffee:
Scoop a tablespoon of batter into a mug, add a jigger of rum (approximately 2 ounces) and pour in hot, fresh-brewed coffee. Stir to combine. Works especially well when mixed in a big thermos, ready to pour.

Keep Reading

Next Up

Mexican Hot Coffee-Chocolate with Chili Cream

Try this twist on Mexican hot chocolate.

Where to Find La Colombe Coffee Around the World

Find out where you can get the coffee as seen on Dangerous Grounds.

9 Questions With Coffee Expert Todd Carmichael

The host of Dangerous Grounds shares his strong opinions on coffee.

Pure Black Velvet Float

Turn this iconic drink into a dessert with ice cream.

7 of the Most Instagram-Worthy Freakshakes You Have to Try

From towering piles of candy to giant brownies and slices of cake, these milkshakes sure know how to pack a sugar-powered punch while maintaining that perfect Instagram-ready look.

10 Over-The-Top Candy Crafted Cocktails

Because kids shouldn't have all the fun.

Winter's Hottest Drinking Destinations

From Canada’s slopes to Cuba’s cobblestone plazas, drinking in winter has never been more après or apropos.

Prague Food and Drink

On this short culinary tour, find out what foods are Czech staples or delicacies, and where to go to get your fill.

Best New Orleans Food and Drink

New Orleans is a city for foodies with fine dining and historic cafes all around the city serving distinctive Creole and Cajun dishes.

No Reservations Destination Drink Guide

No Reservations' Guide to Drinking Around the World.