Watseka Wonder: The Startling Story Of The First Documented Possession

Tales of paranormal activity date back thousands of years, but a tiny Illinois town holds the distinction of being the site of America’s first documented demonic possession.

August 11, 2021
House on the Outskirts of Illinois

In the rural outskirts of the tiny city of Watseka, IL, is an architectural Victorian gem with big arching windows that harbors a frightening secret from the afterlife. [via Discovery Inc.]

In the rural outskirts of the tiny city of Watseka, IL, is an architectural Victorian gem with big arching windows that harbors a frightening secret from the afterlife. [via Discovery Inc.]

Today, Watseka, Illinois, is a quiet midwestern town nestled among wide swaths of farmland about halfway between Chicago and Champaign. In the late 1800s, tales of paranormal happenings in the tiny town were spreading throughout the nation’s newspapers, making Watseka a household name.

Mary Roff was a baby when she had her first “cataleptic fit” and the incidents became worse as she grew. When the girl grew old enough to speak, she told her parents, Dorthy and Asa, that she could speak to spirits when she was in one of her trances. As a teenager, Mary gained the ability to read any book while completely blindfolded and was prone to hours-long

fits where it took up to five grown men to hold her down. She often cut herself with knives, hoping to bleed off a pressure she said she felt in her head. She began hearing voices, and began speaking in different languages she had no way of knowing, according History of Yesterday.

Her desperate parents wanted a cure for their daughter and ultimately decided to commit her to an insane asylum, hoping that she could be treated. Mary died at the age of 19 in 1865.

Mary, Mary, Quite Contrary

It turns out, Mary was neither truly gone nor happy about the death of her body.

On July 11, 1877, another young woman in Watseka, Lurancy Vennum, told her mother she didn’t feel well and laid down. Much like Mary Roff, 13-year-old Lurancy suddenly became prone to long trances where she spoke in different voices and gave details about places she’d never been. The girl also told her parents she’d been communicating with the spirits of two older siblings who had died many years before.

According to Morbidology, doctors wanted the Vennums to send their daughter to an asylum, but they refused. Asa Roff, still reeling from the death of his daughter, wanted to see this other girl with an eerily similar affliction. Asa and a spiritualist who visited the Vennum home noted that Lurancy would introduce herself as different people, including an elderly German woman and a little boy. After meeting Asa, Lurancy introduced herself as Mary and asked to go home.

Lurancy’s body, inhabited by Mary’s spirit, went to the Roff house and lived as Mary for months, even visiting Mary’s friends. Ten months after Lurancy first fell into a trance, the voice of Mary informed the Roffs that Lurancy’s spirit was healed and she’d return soon.

When Mary’s spirit relinquished control of Lurancy’s body, Lurancy was reportedly healed and lived a relatively normal life, according to an Illinois Library article. Mary finally seemed to rest.

Something Still Lingers

In an episode of Ghost Brothers: Lights Out, Dalen, Juwan, and Marcus head out to see what’s still lurking in the Roff house. Hauntings there have reportedly turned dark and aggressive throughout the last hundred years, with a variety of spirits and sometimes violent entities telling paranormal investigators to get out.

You can stream this episode of Ghost Brothers: Lights Out on discovery+.

Next Up

An Elite Team of Paranormal Investigators Race to Help a Petrified Western Town in the New Series Ghosts of Devil's Perch

Dave Schrader, K.D. Stafford and Cindy Kaza go to Butte, Montana to investigate the Ghosts of Devil's Perch, premiering on Travel Channel and discoveryplus August 21st.

Come Party With the Paranormal in Round Two of Fright Club

Jack Osbourne and the Ghost Brothers – Dalen Spratt, Juwan Mass and Marcus Harvey – serve up more paranormal insanity in the hilarious and spooky competition in the all-new season premiering June 30 on Travel Channel and discovery+.

Zak Bagans And The Ghost Adventures Crew Summon Supernatural Terror This 'Ghostober'

"Aaron, Billy, Jay and I pushed ourselves to the extreme with these investigations, physically and mentally, more than anything we’ve ever done before," said Zak Bagans.

Filmmaker Eli Roth Debuts Two New Series And A Halloween Night Special With Zak Bagans For 'Ghostober'

Eli Roth’s projects for Travel Channel and discovery+ are emotional journeys that evoke feelings of fear by turning seemingly ordinary realities into waking nightmares.

11 Of The Scariest Ghost Stories From Reddit

Leave the lights on when you read these bone-chilling stories of average people encountering the paranormal.

The Spirits in the Conjuring House Were Quick to Show Themselves

The spirits in the home that inspired the movie, "The Conjuring," are still active almost 250 years after the house was built.

Global Pop Superstar Kesha Searches for the Supernatural with Her Famous Friends in 'Conjuring Kesha'

Comedian Whitney Cummings and musician Betty Who join Kesha in the first two episodes, premiering Friday, July 8, on discovery+.

Fact Or Fiction? Modern Vampire Lore May Be A Planned Misinformation Campaign

What if vampires are ancient hominids hiding in plain sight? The nation’s only vampire hunters say that’s exactly what’s happening.

‘Ghostober’ Delivers More Than 55 Hours Of Must-See Programming From Travel Channel, Food Network and Discovery+

Paranormal superstar Zak Bagans, Food Network star Sunny Anderson, filmmaker Eli Roth, paranormal investigator Jack Osbourne and actor/comedian John Henson among celebrities set to participate.

Debut Episode of Eli Roth Podcast Explores An Abandoned Indianapolis Asylum Haunting

A new podcast from horror director Eli Roth recounts the terrifying ways the supernatural wrecked the lives of unsuspecting victims.

More Creepy Content

Follow Us Everywhere

Join the party! Don't miss Travel Channel in your favorite social media feeds.