Hidden City Crime File: Florida Keys
Dive into 3 crimes from the Florida Keys.
1. Black Caesar
What: Black Caesar and some of his fellow tribe members were lured onto a slave ship. Caesar and his men tried to overtake the crew, but were subdued. Caesar refused to eat until he made friends with one of the crew members. He would only eat with that man. As the ship approached the US, it crashed on the reefs and Black Caesar and the crew member escaped. They went on to raid ships together until a dispute over a woman led Caesar to kill his friend. Caesar continued to raid ships and accumulated a number of ships and men. He eventually joined forces with Blackbeard. Black Caesar met his demise when he was about to blow up a ship he raided and was overpowered by some of the prisoners on board. He was arrested by Virginian colonial authorities and eventually hanged in Williamsburg, VA, for piracy. It was said he left treasure buried in the Florida Keys.
Where: Black Caesar was born in Africa and ended up on a slave boat that crashed on the reefs off the Florida coast.
When: Caesar raided ships in the 1700s.
In the Media: The descendants of Caesar and his crew are depicted in Albert Payson Terhune's 1922 novel Black Caesar's Clan, which describes people living near Caesar's Creek who chase off treasure hunters looking for Caesar's lost fortune.
2. Dutchy Melville
What: Dutchy and his gang would rob cigar factories and then set fire to them to destroy the evidence. After calling in several favors with family members, Melville could no longer avoid prosecution and was found guilty of grand theft and arson of the Cortez Cigar factory. He was sentenced to 13 years in prison but quickly escaped and fled to the Everglades. Melville ended up going to work for Edgar Watson. What Melville didn’t know was that Watson was a serial killer and none of his help ever left the farm. Melville met the same fate and was killed by 2 of Watson’s groundskeepers.
Where: Melville’s crimes occurred in Key West, FL. After escaping prison, he headed to Monroe County in the Everglades area.
When: Melville and his gang went on their crime spree in the early 1900s. They were finally caught, found guilty and sentenced on May 14, 1908.
3. Bum Farto
What: The Navy had been a powerful force in the Key West economy. When they pulled out many of the forces, the island suffered. Times were hard and people turned to illegal ways to earn a living. Bum Farto was one of those people. He sold marijuana from Colombia and began peddling it while sitting on a bench outside the fire station. From marijuana he moved into cocaine. Eventually authorities ran Operation Conch to take down some of the drug dealers in Key West. Each of the alleged dealers was surprised including Bum Farto. Convicted of selling drugs, Farto was out on bail when he told his wife he had to take care of some things and was never heard from again. One report tied Farto's disappearance to the Mafia in Tampa, FL. Other sources believed he was a victim of Colombian drug lords.
Where: Farto was born and raised in Key West.
When: Farto was married in 1955. He started selling drugs in the 1970s and was arrested and sentenced in 1976.
The Latest: Farto's wife, Esther, filed papers in 2010 asking Monroe County's Probate Division to clear up the legal issue of Farto's fate. She wants them to declare him dead so she can settle his estate and collect any retirement and insurance benefits.
In the Media: Stuart B. McIver's book Touched by the Sun devotes an entire chapter ("Where’s Bum Farto?") to the case. In addition, T-shirts and songs have been written about his disappearance, including "Bum Farto" from Ben Harrison's album Air Sunshine.
Get more information on the Hidden City LA crime stories.
In this Hidden City Crime File we look at 3 stories from the city of Chicago ... H.H. Holmes, John Dillinger and the 1968 Democratic National Convention Riots.
Marcus learns more about 3 crimes in the city of Seattle.
Explore 3 crimes that have occurred in Austin.
Marcus explores 3 crime stories from the city of Atlanta.
Explore 3 crime stories from our nation's capital.
Delve into 3 crime stories from New Orleans.
Try the crossword puzzle, written by NY Times crossword puzzle creator Byron Walden, featured in the San Francisco episode of Hidden City.
Take our quiz to see if you would be considered a psychopath by forensic psychology standards.
Thriller novelist Marcus Sakey knows good stories—and bad behavior. Now Marcus goes from city to city to identify three crimes or criminals that reveal the real character of the place.